[ D R A F T ] Marshall R. Williams, Chief Freedom of Information/Privacy Act Unit Office of Enforcement Operations Criminal Division [sic] U.S. Department of Justice 10th and Constitution, N.W. Washington [zip code exempt] DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA Dear Mr. Williams, Thank you for your letter dated March 13, 1997. I appreciate the fact that you have honored my mailing location exactly as shown on my original FOIA request. I also appreciate the fact that you have referred my FOIA request to the Justice Management Division. I presume you have done this in honor of my request for same on page two (2) of the original FOIA request. For your information, I have already appealed this request, in a proper and timely FOIA appeal submitted to the Disclosure Officer in the Attorney General's office. Your letter goes on to state that I can seek judicial review of this action. You did not, however, specify which federal court has original jurisdiction over a petition to enforce disclosure of documents improperly withheld under the FOIA, and to enjoin withholding of documents properly requested under the FOIA. In your official opinion, is it the United States District Court ("USDC"), or is it the District Court of the United States ("DCUS") which has original jurisdiction over FOIA enforcement? I am asking this question because a federal judge in Arizona, in late spring of 1996, ruled that the USDC is not the proper forum to bring a request under the FOIA. That can only mean that the DCUS is the proper forum. Do you agree or do you disagree? It makes a big difference, because I do not want to petition a court which does not have competent jurisdiction, pursuant to Act of Congress. I will look forward to your timely and considerate response. Respectfully submitted, [not signed] Everett C. Gilbertson, Sui Juris Citizen of Minnesota state (expressly not a federal citizen) All Rights Reserved without Prejudice # # #
Return to Table of Contents for
U.S.A. v. Gilbertson, District Court